Independant Process Servers vs. Sheriff Serve

Advantages of Independent Process Servers Over Sheriffs

Speed and Efficiency

Independent process servers significantly outperform sheriffs in terms of speed. While sheriffs typically take weeks or even months to complete service attempts, private process servers usually accomplish service within 2-3 days. This dramatic difference occurs for multiple reasons, including:

• Specialized Focus: Process serving is the primary and often sole responsibility of private servers, while sheriffs juggle numerous law enforcement duties including criminal investigations, jail management, and courtroom security

• Flexible Scheduling: Private servers can work beyond standard business hours (typically 7am-9pm, seven days a week), while sheriffs generally operate only during 9am-5pm weekdays

• No Backlog Issues: Sheriff departments often have significant backlogs of service requests, while private servers can begin attempts immediately

Superior Due Diligence and Persistence

Independent process servers demonstrate a higher level of commitment to successful service through a combination of persistence, thoroughness, and creative problem-solving. Unlike sheriffs, who may make limited attempts and simply return documents marked "moved," professional servers employ multiple strategic attempts at various times and locations. They utilize investigative tools such as skip tracing to locate evasive individuals and adapt their approach based on real-time findings. Their documentation is detailed and informative, often including notes on conversations with neighbors, observations about the property, and potential leads for future attempts. Additionally, independent servers are skilled at devising tailored strategies for challenging serves; conducting stakeouts, checking signs of activity like warm car hoods or recent utility use, and coordinating closely with clients to execute service at optimal times. This level of diligence ensures a higher rate of successful and timely service.

Enhanced Customer Service and Communication

Private process servers operate as accountable businesses, prioritizing client satisfaction through responsive communication, detailed reporting, and customized service. Unlike sheriff departments, where status updates may be delayed by days, professional servers maintain prompt, reliable communication, ensuring clients are kept informed throughout the service process. Their documentation is comprehensive, recording each attempt with dates, times, circumstances, and recommended next steps. Additionally, private servers offer a level of flexibility that government agencies cannot, accommodating specific client requests such as serving at targeted times or locations when the defendant is most likely to be present. This client-focused approach enhances efficiency, transparency, and overall success in service of process.

Higher Success Rates

Studies show private process servers achieve significantly higher success rates, with a 92% higher success rate when law firms use private servers versus sheriffs; While being 58% more knowledgeable about current process serving laws and regulations.

Some servers also have access to specialized resources including skip trace investigators, database searches, and surveillance techniques that sheriffs cannot dedicate time to utilize.

Specialized Legal Knowledge

Process servers maintain current expertise in service of process law, which varies by jurisdiction and changes regularly. For example, different California counties have varying due diligence requirements - San Francisco County requires four attempts while Marin County requires three. Sheriffs, dealing with broad law enforcement responsibilities, may not stay current with these nuanced procedural requirements.

Court Testimony and Follow-Up

Professional process servers are prepared to testify in court about their service attempts if needed, providing detailed accounts of their actions. Sheriffs may be reluctant or unavailable to appear in court for process serving matters, potentially leaving gaps in the legal record.

Limitations of Sheriff-Provided Service

Sheriff departments face inherent constraints that limit their effectiveness in process serving. these include:

• Competing Priorities: Process serving often ranks low among sheriff responsibilities, behind criminal enforcement, emergency response, and jail operations

• Limited Attempts: Sheriffs typically make minimal attempts (often just 2-3) before returning papers as undeliverable

• Restricted Hours: Service attempts are generally limited to business hours when many defendants are at work

• Reduced Accountability: As public servants, sheriffs face less direct accountability for process serving performance compared to private businesses dependent on client satisfaction

The evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that independent process servers provide superior service through their specialization, flexibility, persistence, and commitment to successful outcomes. While sheriffs serve an important role in the justice system, their broad responsibilities and operational constraints make them less effective for the specialized task of process serving, particularly in cases requiring due diligence and multiple attempts to locate defendants.

Work With Dedicated Professionals